Heard part of this interview on talk radio last night and found it on YouTube (fast forward to 4:43):
Interesting perspective from Mr. Edwards. All this time I thought the 2nd Amendment to the US Constitution established the right to bear arms:
A well regulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms, shall not be infringed.
Yep.. seems pretty clear. So why does Mr. Edwards believe this is a privilege? Privileges can be taken away or infringed; rights can not. So, does Mr. Edwards believe the “privilege” to bear arms can be taken away from us?
Rights, on the other hand, are guaranteed under the Constitution. Free speech, freedom of (not from) religion, voting… these we all have a universal right to in the United States of America.
What rights does John Edwards believe we have?
For this to be a right, every citizen would be guaranteed a college education. The quality of this education would presumably still be variable, but does right in this case indicate that everyone would be entitled to a college education even if they could not afford one, or would they only have the right to a college education if they could afford one?
Although the 2nd Amendment establishes the right to bear arms, if I can not afford a gun, does that mean I am entitled to own a gun and the United States must provide me with one?
So what I think John Edwards is really saying here is that everyone should have equal access to a college education regardless of means, essentially defining college as an entitlement. Who pays for entitlements? That would be you and me via taxes.
- Health care
- Access to the internet
- A livable wage
The same pretty much goes for these “rights”. Although there is no explicit constitutional amendment to cover access to the internet, livable wages or health care, there is nothing blocking our access to these “rights” except our own abilities or means to afford them. On the other hand, if we are entitled to these, who pays?
If internet access is a right, what if I don’t pay my bill to my ISP, can they not shut down my access? If I refuse to pay my doctor, must he still continue to schedule me for yearly check-ups? If I’m elected to the senate but fail to show up for most votes and then 2 years in run for VP, keeping me away from the senate floor for weeks, should I still get paid… ah wait.. bad example.
I might give Mr. Edwards a pass on all of these if it were not for his characterization of owning a gun as a privilege. In so doing, he establishes health care, internet access, a livable wage and a college education as having a higher guarantee of access than gun ownership.
Again, if right=entitlement, who pays? You and me.
- US Citizenship after 5 years residency
So now US Citizenship is a right if you live and work here for 5 years? Wow. Why don’t the Dems just come right out and admit that this is nothing more than their way of building a base of voters by expanding the ranks of those who receive while proportionally reducing the ranks of those who give (read:have taken from) in the redistribution of wealth that is the foundation of the Democrat strategy for bought and paid for elections. After all, if we could just reach a point where 51% of the country is reliant upon Democrat wealth redistribution programs, the Democrats plan to “take back America” will have been funded by those of us who actually earn enough money to pay taxes.
A couple of other interesting points on this video:
- If elected, John Edwards will tour the world for the first six months (2:05). Reminds me of Disney’s Super Bowl commercial… John Edwards, you’ve just been elected president, what are you going to do? “Leave the country and travel the world for the 6 months”.
- John Edwards feels America must do some things to show the world we are not selfish.. translation…. open up your wallets folks, the gravy train is leaving the country.
- Clever answer to the question of his biggest fault (3:30). He says sometimes he takes too long to make a decision because he wants to get a lot of information before making the decision. Wow! I need to remember that one for my next job interview.
His most honest answer? At (1:25) he admits that if we follow his plan for pulling out of Iraq he has no idea what the impact will be in Iraq. I suppose this was not one of those “sometimes” when he did a lot of research and spent too much time making a decision…